Cultural relativism is the idea that a culture’s beliefs, values, and practices should be understood and judged within the context of that particular culture, rather than from the viewpoint of one’s own culture. It is a concept that has been debated and discussed for centuries, with its origins tracing back to ancient Greek philosophers such as Protagoras and Herodotus. However, it wasn’t until the 20th century that cultural relativism emerged as a significant concept in the study of anthropology and sociology.
The term “cultural relativism” was coined by Franz Boas, known as the father of American anthropology, in the late 19th and early 20th century. Boas believed that each culture should be studied independently, with an emphasis on understanding the unique customs, beliefs, and values of a society without imposing one’s own cultural biases. He argued that cultural relativism was necessary to combat ethnocentrism, the belief in the superiority of one’s own culture over others.
Boas’ ideas were further developed by anthropologist Ruth Benedict in her influential book, “Patterns of Culture” (1934). Benedict argued that different cultures had distinct worldviews, and each one was equally valid and meaningful. She used examples from different societies such as the Zuni of New Mexico and the Dobu of New Guinea to illustrate how cultural norms and values shape individuals’ behavior and understanding of the world.
The concept of cultural relativism was also embraced by anthropologist Margaret Mead, whose studies of different cultures in the South Pacific challenged the Western notions of gender and sexuality. She argued that the social norms and expectations regarding gender roles and sexual behavior were culturally constructed, and what was considered “normal” varied from one society to another.
The acceptance of cultural relativism in the field of anthropology was not without controversy. The idea of suspending judgment and understanding other cultures on their own terms was seen as a threat to Western cultural superiority. Critics argued that it could lead to moral relativism, the belief that there is no universal standard of right and wrong, and that all cultural practices should be accepted as equally valid.
However, the impact of cultural relativism went beyond the academic world. It played a crucial role in the decolonization process of many countries in the mid-20th century. As Western powers withdrew from their colonies, they had to confront the reality that their cultural practices and ideologies were not necessarily superior to those of the colonized societies. This led to a re-evaluation of Western attitudes and behaviors towards other cultures and a greater acknowledgment of cultural diversity.
One of the most significant practical applications of cultural relativism can be seen in the field of human rights. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations in 1948, recognizes that human rights should be upheld regardless of cultural differences. This acknowledges the importance of cultural diversity while also setting universal standards for the protection of basic human rights.
However, cultural relativism is not without its limitations. Critics argue that it can be used to justify human rights violations, particularly in cultures where practices such as child marriage or female genital mutilation are considered acceptable. In response, proponents of cultural relativism argue that the concept should not be used to condone harmful practices, but rather to promote a better understanding of cultural differences and to find ways to respect cultural diversity while also upholding universal human rights.
In conclusion, the history of cultural relativism is a complex one, characterized by ongoing debates and discussions about its implications and limitations. While some view it as a way to promote understanding and acceptance of cultural diversity, others see it as a threat to universal values and human rights. Nevertheless, cultural relativism remains a crucial concept in the study of anthropology and sociology, helping us to better appreciate the unique beliefs, values, and practices of different cultures and challenging us to see the world through a more open and empathetic lens.